Best Magic: The Gathering — Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles Play Booster Box deal: Below market value at Amazon

BELOW MARKET VALUE: As of Nov. 3, the Magic: The Gathering — Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles Play Booster Box is $209.70 at Amazon, compared to TCGplayer’s price of $231.99.

Universes Beyond is on fire right now. We’ve already had Marvel’s Spider-Man and Avatar: The Last Air Bender hit digital and store shelves on Nov. 21, and now the next Magic: The Gathering Universes Beyond set is taking us back to the sewers with Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles on March 6, 2026. So why not lock your preorder in?

The Magic: The Gathering — Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles Play Booster Box is $209.70 at Amazon, that’s $22.29 cheaper than the current going rate on TCGplayer, meaning Amazon is well below market value. You’ll also get their preorder price guarantee and won’t be charged for it until it ships. That’s a win-win situation.

Each of the 30 boosters in this display box has 14 cards, ranging from 1-4 rares or mythics, 3-6 uncommons, and 6-9 commons. If you’re after pulling rare cards, your chances are between 1% and 25%, with Full Boarderless Mythic Rare Turtles having a pull chance of under 1%. So if you’re planning on pulling one, you’re going to be opening a lot of boosters.

Most valuable Magic: The Gathering — Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles cards

We’re already seeing presale listings for single Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtle MTG cards over on TCGplayer, which means you can snag some in-demand cards now before prices blow up near release next year. There’s always a chance single card prices will go down, but we’re not seeing any downward trends on the top chase cards from other Universes Beyond sets.

Here’s the top five most valuable MTG Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles cards you can pre-order right now:

1. Super Shredder #83
   Near Mint Holofoil: $60
   Market price: $60
   Most recent sale: $60

2. Leonardo, the Balance (Borderless) #1
   Near Mint Holofoil: $45
   Market price: N/A
   Most recent sale: N/A

3. Splinter, the Mentor (Borderless) #3
   Near Mint Holofoil: $45
   Market price: N/A
   Most recent sale: N/A

4. Heroes in a Half Shell (Borderless) #6
   Near Mint Holofoil: $45
   Market price: N/A
   Most recent sale: N/A

5. Krang, Master Mind #43
   Near Mint Holofoil: $30
   Market price: $30
   Most recent sale: $30