VGChartz’s Lee Mehr: “In one sense, it feels strange to even think Pieces Interactive had big shoes to fill with this series’ legacy. Given what’s come before, did it really? And yet, even when considering the last two flops over a two-decade span, there’s still something about Alone in the Dark emblazoned on a title screen that carries a sense of revered history. In that respect, perhaps this reboot’s best accomplishment is in honoring that spirit through its inventive world. It’s also fair to emphasize knocks against its survival-horror design, some puzzle-solving, and so on; it certainly won’t be considered a trendsetter like the 1992 classic. Still, the amount of goodwill wedded to its brighter qualities makes for something that dawdles the line between unfortunately-flawed and impressively-enticing.”
