The UK’s Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) has published the main party responses in its Interim report on Nexfibre’s proposed £2bn acquisition of Netomnia, outlining continued competitive concerns regarding the move, but which the concerned parties have condemned for ignoring “real-world evidence” of “how competition actually operates” in the UK full-fibre broadband market.
The acquisition was first announced in February 2026 and would see wholesale full-fibre gigabit broadband network provider Nexfibre acquire Substantial Topco and its subsidiaries – including independent broadband providers (altnets) Brsk, YouFibre and Netomnia.
The Netomnia element alone is valued at £2bn, and Nexfibre says the acquisition would unlock a value of £3.5bn, creating what it called sustainable, scaled network competition and enhanced wholesale choice in the UK.
On 11 June 2026, Nexfibre and Substantial requested the CMA to make a fast-track reference for an in-depth investigation of the takeover at Phase 2. After studying their proposal, the CMA concluded that the conditions to accept a fast-track reference request under UK competition law have been met, and that it would be appropriate to accept the fast-track reference request and proceed to a Phase 2 investigation.
After originally fast-tracking the deal, the UK’s Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) revealed on 2 October 2026 that it had provisionally found factors that may result in a substantial lessening of competition (SLC) in the wholesale supply of fixed broadband services.
In a filing explaining its decision, the CMA said that in assessing the competitive effects of the deal it had looked at a wide range of evidence which it has considered in the round in reaching its provisional conclusions.
To determine what impact the acquisition may be expected to have on competition, the CMA considered what would likely happen if the deal did not take place – the counterfactual which considered whether the absence of the Nexfibre deal would make it more likely that Substantial would have remained as a standalone entity or would have been acquired by rival CityFibre.
The CMA then assessed whether the deal may be expected to result in an SLC compared to the counterfactual. The CMA stressed that the counterfactual had been a key focus of the inquiry and that it had considered the relevant counterfactual for each of Substantial, Nexfibre and VMO2.
On 13 November 2026, the CMA released the main party responses in its Interim report on the proposed acquisition, incurring the corporate wrath of Nexfibre and Netomnia, in whose opinion the findings “depend almost entirely on a foundational error”, that is that CityFibre would have acquired Netomnia. This, they said, rests on “an imagined” funding position and that in reality, CityFibre tried to acquire Netomnia but could not commit the funds.
Furthermore, Nexfibre and Netomnia say the CMA has “relied heavily on speculative views” of potential future market developments, while ignoring real-world evidence of how competition actually operates in the UK full-fibre market. They added that prohibition would block the only viable deal that can immediately create a scaled competitor to market leader Openreach, and this in turn will have a chilling effect on investment for the altnet market.
“Our response, and that of Substantial Group, exposes the fundamental weakness at the heart of the Interim report: its findings rest on highly speculative assumptions that lack evidence and are increasingly contradicted by commercial reality,” said Nexfibre CEO Rajiv Datta.
“The market has spoken, and the clear weight of industry opinion has further exposed just how flawed the CMA’s counterfactuals are,” he said. “The CMA cannot simply wish away the facts. CityFibre was unable to fund a transaction and is now undergoing a massive debt restructuring, while Virgin Media O2 has halted further fibre investment.
“The UK broadband market is too important to get this wrong,” said Datta. “The writing is on the wall. The CMA must now confront the commercial and financial reality in front of it, rather than condemn the sector to further uncertainty and underinvestment on the basis of counter-fantasy.”


