A federal judge has denied Meta‘s attempt to dismiss a lawsuit claiming it violated copyright law by torrenting (illegally downloading) porn to train its AI.
On June 11, U.S. District Judge Eumi K. Lee filed the order, stating that porn holding company, Strike 3 Holdings, and Counterlife Media (in which Strike 3 has a majority ownership interest), “have plausibly alleged that [Meta] is liable for direct, vicarious, and contributatory copyright infringement based on the torrenting of their films.”
Strike 3 Holdings, which owns several popular porn sites like Blacked, according to 404 Media, first filed the lawsuit in July 2025. Strike 3 Holdings and Counterlife Media alleged that, between 2018 and 2025, Meta infringed on more than 2,300 copyrighted pornographic movies by downloading them to train its AI models. Meta is alleged to have used the popular torrenting program BitTorrent.
IP addresses that trace back to Meta’s corporate offices acted “consistently in non-human patterns,” the suit states, “involving mass infringement beyond what a human could consume.” The companies are seeking damages up to $359 million.
Mashable Light Speed
Meta filed the motion to dismiss against the Strike 3 lawsuit in Oct., denying the claims and stating that they were “nonsensical and unsupported” and that the porn downloads were for “personal use.” But in the order denying the motion, Lee remarked on the download patterns, such as the IP addresses torrenting similar files with the same name, all in one day, from cartoons to porn. “It strains credulity to suggest that these correlations are mere coincidence and the product of individual human selections,” Lee wrote.
Now, the lawsuit can proceed.
Strike 3 and Counterlife Media became aware of Meta’s BitTorrent activity through press coverage of the Jan. 2025 lawsuit against Meta. Discovery in that case revealed that the company pirated books for AI training. In June 2025, Meta won the case. However, as Mashable reported at the time, the judge in that case wrote that the plaintiffs may have been successful if they had made different legal arguments, leaving the door open for suits such as this one.
Mashable has reached out to Meta for comment.
Topics
Artificial Intelligence
Meta
